What is religion?

 
Anonymous
 
Avatar
 
 
Anonymous
Total Posts:  2957
Joined  02-12-2004
 
 
 
09 June 2005 11:14
 

I have a question, and I would like a secularist’s honest opinion. When evidence is compiled against Christianity – for example racism in the church, witch burnings, and public discrimination against other religions - is the criticism against organized religion or religious thought and beliefs as a whole?

I’m only asking because I see more evidence against religion based upon organizations and not upon the philosophies and ideologies that make up that religion.

 
roger_pearse
 
Avatar
 
 
roger_pearse
Total Posts:  253
Joined  29-05-2005
 
 
 
09 June 2005 12:23
 

[quote author=“Anonymous”]I have a question, and I would like a secularist’s honest opinion. When evidence is compiled against Christianity – for example racism in the church, witch burnings, and public discrimination against other religions - is the criticism against organized religion or religious thought and beliefs as a whole?

I’m only asking because I see more evidence against religion based upon organizations and not upon the philosophies and ideologies that make up that religion.

Since I’m a Christian, you aren’t asking me and I won’t stand in the way of your question.

I’d merely like to add that I think getting clear what we’re talking about is definitely essential.  Try not using the word ‘religion’ and see if you can still articulate what you mean.  If we can’t, probably all we’re doing is sticking a stereotype on something.  Just my tip, for what its worth.  Clarity is always worth cultivating.  The things we want to believe are the things that will lead us astray.

Best of luck getting a decent answer.

All the best,

Roger Pearse

 
 
Avatar
 
 
nv
Total Posts:  2821
Joined  29-04-2005
 
 
 
09 June 2005 17:17
 

[quote author=“Anonymous”]I have a question, and I would like a secularist’s honest opinion. When evidence is compiled against Christianity – for example racism in the church, witch burnings, and public discrimination against other religions - is the criticism against organized religion or religious thought and beliefs as a whole?

I’m only asking because I see more evidence against religion based upon organizations and not upon the philosophies and ideologies that make up that religion.

Anon, this is such a subtle question that I have no idea how to respond to it except to say that I have many answers to your question. Roger’s input also triggers all kinds of motivations in me to respond, but my work is consuming almost all of my time and energy these days, as it will for the next year or so. If my opinion would mean something to you, private-message me and I’ll send you an 85,000-word manuscript that’s only been turned down by one publisher so far. I guarantee that it would answer your eloquent question. No charge for the printing costs if you agree to write at least one critiquing paragraph for every chapter you choose to read.