Purpose of life etc

 
 
Avatar
 
 
vargaj
Total Posts:  1
Joined  24-11-2009
 
 
 
09 September 2011 18:03
 

In his latest missive Sam takes aim at the use of the questions often used by Christians as teaching aides, such as “What is the meaning of life?” and “what is our purpose on earth?”. Sam says they are badly posed. I would like to know how he would pose a better question. i think they do address topics that people have been asking themselves for a long time. It would be helpful to see a better question and perhaps a worthy answer as well.

Joe varg

 
 
 
Avatar
 
 
J.v.d.A.
Total Posts:  4
Joined  04-03-2009
 
 
 
11 September 2011 17:09
 

Christians pose them as completely loaded questions. They ask them because they believe those questions are road signs which point to the truth of their faith.

 
 
Avatar
 
 
Vallhall
Total Posts:  20
Joined  13-11-2011
 
 
 
13 November 2011 10:22
 

Questions like “what is the meaning of life?” or “purpose of life?”, are perhaps only defined as questions because we need to structure thought in some way or another. When we think of questions, we usually understand them as related and part of some answer. The questions mentioned are different from our usual definition of what questions are, as they have no answer. They are nonetheless useful as philosophical tools that move the mind towards the borders of the unknown.

What I think of when I use the image of moving the mind towards the borders of the unknown, can perhaps best be explained by using words and concepts more familiar. The scientific method producing the temporary truths that guides us in the reality we are forced to relate to, is a tool with foundation and root in the hypothesis. So what is in truth the hypothesis? It is a claim of knowing the unknown, looking past borders and limits presently existing. For what need would testing and examination of result be, if the hypothesis related to other than faith, belief and imagination.

When asking questions, the answer is the preferred part of a duality. In other words, answers have meaning only in relation its alternatives. The least amount of alternatives needed is one, as in yes/no or on/off to show examples. This brings us to the essential issue. Do we know anything at all, or can we even know anything at all, about something other than life? Is there any known alternatives to life, that give reason to claim dependency of purpose of meaning?

Perhaps I understand the topic and discussion wrong, and meaning or purpose of life is directed at the individual level only. Even so, the individuality itself contradicts any answer beyond arguments founded on philosophical thought.

It would be helpful to see a better question and perhaps a worthy answer as well.

As to posing questions mentioned in a better way, in hope of receiving better answers, the search would be similar to finding the beginning and end of infinity. Quality of question, and value of answer are subjective qualities that reveal this being something only relevant as philosophical thoughts. Finding questions and answers based on willingness to accept, is something I would strongly recommend not trying at a math test to name one area.

When Sam Harris says questions mentioned are badly posed, it could be that he thinks in terms of the confusing mess I have tried to communicate. Badly posed, not as in it could be posed differently. But badly posed as in asking questions that can not be answered. Sam Harris is a neuroscientist, and knows very well that the mind and our perception of reality is the works of a mind that is adaptive. Adaptive as it functions according to the environment it relates to.

If I claimed the purpose and meaning of life was not to die. Would that answer give satisfaction?

 
 
Avatar
 
 
Maestro
Total Posts:  1
Joined  04-12-2011
 
 
 
05 December 2011 06:25
 

Please ignore this post.

[ Edited: 23 December 2011 14:47 by Maestro]
 
 
Avatar
 
 
kman0328
Total Posts:  5
Joined  14-12-2011
 
 
 
14 December 2011 22:33
 

I think we just all need to feel that we are here for a purpose.  Obviously we can all choose purposes based on our gifts and strengths.

 
 
Avatar
 
 
toombaru
Total Posts:  800
Joined  12-11-2010
 
 
 
26 December 2011 13:26
 
vargaj - 09 September 2011 10:03 PM

In his latest missive Sam takes aim at the use of the questions often used by Christians as teaching aides, such as “What is the meaning of life?” and “what is our purpose on earth?”. Sam says they are badly posed. I would like to know how he would pose a better question. i think they do address topics that people have been asking themselves for a long time. It would be helpful to see a better question and perhaps a worthy answer as well.

Joe varg

 

It would be as meaningful to ask the “purpose” of a character in your night time dreams.
What is the “purpose” of a hummingbird or an oak tree?